MPAS_ATM

Overview

This document describes the DART interface module for the atmospheric component of the Model for Prediction Across Scales MPAS (or briefly, MPAS-ATM) global model, which uses an unstructured Voronoi grid mesh, formally Spherical Centriodal Voronoi Tesselations (SCVTs). This allows for both quasi-uniform discretization of the sphere and local refinement. The MPAS/DART interface was built on the SCVT-dual mesh and does not regrid to regular lat/lon grids. In the C-grid discretization, the normal component of velocity on cell edges is prognosed; zonal and meridional wind components are diagnosed on the cell centers. We provide several options to choose from in the assimilation of wind observations as shown below.

The grid terminology used in MPAS is as shown in the figure below:

MPAS_grid_structure

The wind options during a DART assimilation are controlled by combinations of 4 different namelist values. The values determine which fields the forward operator uses to compute expected observation values; how the horizontal interpolation is computed in that forward operator; and how the assimilation increments are applied to update the wind quantities in the state vector. Preliminary results based on real data assimilation experiments indicate that performance is better when the zonal and meridional winds are used as input to the forward operator that uses Barycentric interpolation, and when the prognostic u wind is updated by the incremental method described in the figure below. However there remain scientific questions about how best to handle the wind fields under different situations. Thus we have kept all implemented options available for use in experimental comparisons. See the figure below for a flow-chart representation of how the 4 namelist items interact:

WindDA_options

Cycling of MPAS/DART is run in a restart mode. As for all DART experiments, the overall design for an experiment is this: the DART program filter will read the initial condition file, the observation sequence file, and the DART namelist to decide whether or not to advance the MPAS-ATM model. All of the control of the execution of the MPAS model is done by DART directly. If the model needs to be advanced, filter makes a call to the shell to execute the script advance_model.csh, which is ENTIRELY responsible for getting all the input files, data files, namelists, etc. into a temporary directory, running the model, and copying the results back to the parent directory (which we call CENTRALDIR). The whole process hinges on setting the MPAS-ATM model namelist values such that it is doing a restart for every model advance. Unlike MPAS-ATM free forecast runs, the forecast step in MPAS/DART requires to set up one more namelist parameter called config_do_DAcycling = .true. in &restart section of namelist.input to recouple the state vectors (updated by filter) with the mass field for the restart mode. For more information, check the advance_model.csh script in ./shell_scripts/ directory.

Since DART is an ensemble algorithm, there are multiple analysis files for a single analysis time: one for each ensemble member. Because MPAS/DART is run in a restart mode, each member should keep its own MPAS restart file from the previous cycle (rather than having a single template file in CENTRALDIR). Creating the initial ensemble of states is an area of active research.

Namelist

This namelist is read from the file input.nml. Namelists start with an ampersand ‘&’ and terminate with a slash ‘/’. Character strings that contain a ‘/’ must be enclosed in quotes to prevent them from prematurely terminating the namelist.

&model_nml
   init_template_filename       = 'mpas_init.nc',
   vert_localization_coord      = 3,
   assimilation_period_days     = 0,
   assimilation_period_seconds  = 21600,
   model_perturbation_amplitude = 0.0001,
   log_p_vert_interp            = .true.,
   calendar                     = 'Gregorian',
   use_u_for_wind               = .false.,
   use_rbf_option               = 2,
   update_u_from_reconstruct    = .true.,
   use_increments_for_u_update  = .true.,
   highest_obs_pressure_mb      = 100.0,
   sfc_elev_max_diff            = -1.0,
   outside_grid_level_tolerance = -1.0,
   extrapolate                  = .false.,
   debug                        = 0,
/

Item

Type

Description

init_template_filename

character(len=256) [default: ‘mpas_init.nc’]

The name of the MPAS analysis file to be read and/or written by the DART programs for the state data.

highest_obs_pressure_mb

real(r8) [default: 100.0]

Observations higher than this pressure are ignored. Set to -1.0 to ignore this test. For models with a prescribed top boundary layer, trying to assimilate very high observations results in problems because the model damps out any changes the assimilation tries to make. With adaptive algorithms this results in larger and larger coefficients as the assimilation tries to effect state vector change.

assimilation_period_days

integer [default: 0]

The number of days to advance the model for each assimilation. Even if the model is being advanced outside of the DART filter program, the assimilation period should be set correctly. Only observations with a time within +/- 1/2 this window size will be assimilated.

assimilation_period_seconds

integer [default: 21600]

In addition to assimilation_period_days, the number of seconds to advance the model for each assimilation.

vert_localization_coord

integer [default: 3]

Vertical coordinate for vertical localization.

  • 1 = model level

  • 2 = pressure (in pascals)

  • 3 = height (in meters)

  • 4 = scale height (unitless)

sfc_elev_max_diff

real(r8)[default: -1.0]

If > 0, the maximum difference, in meters, between an observation marked as a ‘surface obs’ as the vertical type (with the surface elevation, in meters, as the numerical vertical location), and the surface elevation as defined by the model. Observations further away from the surface than this threshold are rejected and not assimilated. If the value is negative, this test is skipped.

log_p_vert_interp

logical [default: .true.]

If .true., vertical interpolation is done in log-pressure. Otherwise, linear.

use_u_for_wind

logical [default: .false.]

If .false., zonal and meridional winds at cell centers are used for the wind observation operator [default]. In that case, triangular meshes are used for the barycentric (e.g., area-weighted) interpolation. If .true., wind vectors at an arbitrary (e.g., observation) point are reconstructed from the normal component of velocity on cell edges (u) using radial basis functions (RBFs) provided by the MPAS model.

use_rbf_option

integer [default: 2]

If use_u_for_wind = .true., this option controls how many points will be used in the RBF interpolation. Options are available as 0, 1, 2, and 3. All the edges available in N (= 0,1,2, or 3) neighboring cells go into the RBF reconstruction.

update_u_from_reconstruct

logical [default: .true.]

When zonal and meridional winds at cell centers are used for the wind observation operator (use_u_for_wind = .false.), this option decides if the normal component of velocity on cell edges (which is the only wind prognostic variable in MPAS-ATM) should be updated from the winds at cell centers. If .true., use_increments_for_u_update should be also decided. If use_u_for_wind = .true. and the normal component of velocity on cell edges is defined as a state vector, this option should be .false. so the edge winds can be directly updated by filter.

use_increments_for_u_update

logical [default: .true.]

Only if update_u_from_reconstruct = .true., this option is used to decide if the edge winds are replaced by averaging from the analysis winds at cell centers (.false.), or just updated by the analysis increments at cell centers (.true.). If .true., all the wind components (e.g., both at cell centers and edges) are read from prior and used to compute the increments [Recommended].

model_perturbation_amplitude

real(r8) [default: 0.0001]

The amplitude of random noise to add when trying to perturb a single state vector to create an ensemble. Only used when start_from_restart = .false. in the &filter_nml namelist within input.nml Multiplied by the state vector, it produces standard deviation of a gaussian distribution with the mean at the value of the state vector element.

calendar

character(len=32) [default: ‘Gregorian’]

Character string specifying the calendar being used by MPAS.

outside_grid_level_tolerance

real(r8) [default: -1.0]

If greater than 0.0, amount of distance in fractional model levels that a vertical location can be above or below the top or bottom of the grid and still be evaluated without error. Since extrapolate is not implemented yet, the value of .false. will be assumed. In this case, vertical locations equivalent to level 1 or level N will be used. Eventually, if extrapolate is .true., extrapolate from the first or last model level. If extrapolate is .false., simply use the value at level 1 for low vertical locations, or at level N for high vertical locations.

extrapolate

logical [default: .false.]

NOT IMPLEMENTED YET. Vertical locations equivalant to level 1 or level N will be used. When this is implemented, it will do: If outside_grid_level_tolerance is greater than 0.0, then control how values are assigned to locations where the vertical is exterior to the grid. If this is .true., then extrapolate low locations from levels 1 and 2, and high locations from levels N-1 and N. If this is .false., then simply use the corresponding values at level 1 or N. This item is ignored if outside_grid_level_tolerance is less than or equal to 0.0.

debug

integer [default: 0]

The switch to specify the run-time verbosity.

  • 0 is as quiet as it gets

  • >1 prints more run-time messages

  • >5 prints ALL run-time messages

The &mpas_vars_nml namelist within input.nml contains the list of MPAS variables that make up the DART state vector. The order the items are specified controls the order of the data in the state vector, so it should not be changed without regenerating all DART initial condition or restart files. These variables are directly updated by the filter assimilation.

Any variables whose values cannot exceed a given minimum or maximum can be listed in mpas_state_bounds. When the data is written back into the MPAS NetCDF files values outside the allowed range will be detected and changed. Data inside the DART state vector and data written to the DART diagnostic files will not go through this test and values may exceed the allowed limits. Note that changing values at the edges of the distribution means it is no longer completely gaussian. In practice this technique has worked effectively, but if the assimilation is continually trying to move the values outside the permitted range the results may be of poor quality. Examine the diagnostics for these fields carefully when using bounds to restrict their values.

&mpas_vars_nml
   mpas_state_variables = 'theta',                 'QTY_POTENTIAL_TEMPERATURE',
                          'uReconstructZonal',     'QTY_U_WIND_COMPONENT',
                          'uReconstructMeridional','QTY_V_WIND_COMPONENT',
                          'qv',                    'QTY_VAPOR_MIXING_RATIO',
                          'qc',                    'QTY_CLOUDWATER_MIXING_RATIO',
                          'surface_pressure',      'QTY_SURFACE_PRESSURE'
   mpas_state_bounds    = 'qv','0.0','NULL','CLAMP',
                          'qc','0.0','NULL','CLAMP',
/

Item

Type

Description

mpas_vars_nml

character(len=NF90_MAX_NAME):: dimension(160)

The table that both specifies which MPAS-ATM variables will be placed in the state vector, and also relates those variables to the corresponding DART kinds. The first column in each pair must be the exact NetCDF name of a field in the MPAS file. The second column in each pair must be a KIND known to the DART system. See the obs_kind_mod.f90 file within assimilation_code/modules/observations/ for known names. This file is autogenerated when DART builds filter for a particular model, so run quickbuild.sh in the work directory first before examining this file. Use the generic kind list in the obs_kind_mod tables, not the specific type list.

mpas_state_bounds

character(len=NF90_MAX_NAME):: dimension(160)

List only MPAS-ATM variables that must restrict their values to remain between given lower and/or upper bounds. Columns are: NetCDF variable name, min value, max value, and action to take for out-of-range values. Either min or max can have the string ‘NULL’ to indicate no limiting will be done. If the action is ‘CLAMP’ out of range values will be changed to the corresponding bound and execution continues; ‘FAIL’ stops the executable if out of range values are detected.

Grid Information

As the forward operators use the unstructured grid meshes in MPAS-ATM, the DART/MPAS interface needs to read static variables related to the grid structure from the MPAS ATM ‘history’ file (specified in model_analysis_filename). These variables are used to find the closest cell to an observation point in the cartesian coordinate (to avoid the polar issues).

integer :: nCells

the number of cell centers

integer :: nEdges

the number of cell edges

integer :: nVertices

the number of cell vertices

integer :: nVertLevels

the number of vertical levels for mass fields

integer :: nVertLevelsP1

the number of vertical levels for vertical velocity

integer :: nSoilLevels

the number of soil levels

real(r8) :: latCell(:)

the latitudes of the cell centers [-90,90]

real(r8) :: lonCell(:)

the longitudes of the cell centers [0, 360]

real(r8) :: latEdge(:)

the latitudes of the edges [-90,90], if edge winds are used.

real(r8) :: lonEdge(:)

the longitudes of the edges [0, 360], if edge winds are used.

real(r8) :: xVertex(:)

The cartesian location in x-axis of the vertex

real(r8) :: yVertex(:)

The cartesian location in y-axis of the vertex

real(r8) :: zVertex(:)

The cartesian location in z-axis of the vertex

real(r8) :: xEdge(:)

The cartesian location in x-axis of the edge, if edge winds are used.

real(r8) :: yEdge(:)

The cartesian location in y-axis of the edge, if edge winds are used.

real(r8) :: zEdge(:)

The cartesian location in z-axis of the edge, if edge winds are used.

real(r8) :: zgrid(:,:)

geometric height at cell centers (nCells, nVertLevelsP1)

integer :: CellsOnVertex(:,:)

list of cell centers defining a triangle

integer :: edgesOnCell(:,:)

list of edges on each cell

integer :: verticesOnCell(:,:)

list of vertices on each cell

integer :: edgeNormalVectors(:,:)

unit direction vectors on the edges (only used if use_u_for_wind = .true.)

model_mod variable storage

The &mpas_vars_nml within input.nml defines the list of MPAS variables used to build the DART state vector. Combined with an MPAS analysis file, the information is used to determine the size of the DART state vector and derive the metadata. To keep track of what variables are contained in the DART state vector, an array of a user-defined type called “progvar” is available with the following components:

type progvartype
   private
   character(len=NF90_MAX_NAME) :: varname
   character(len=NF90_MAX_NAME) :: long_name
   character(len=NF90_MAX_NAME) :: units
   character(len=NF90_MAX_NAME), dimension(NF90_MAX_VAR_DIMS) :: dimname
   integer, dimension(NF90_MAX_VAR_DIMS) :: dimlens
   integer :: xtype         ! netCDF variable type (NF90_double, etc.)
   integer :: numdims       ! number of dimensions - excluding TIME
   integer :: numvertical   ! number of vertical levels in variable
   integer :: numcells      ! number of cell locations (typically cell centers)
   integer :: numedges      ! number of edge locations (edges for normal velocity)
   logical :: ZonHalf       ! vertical coordinate for mass fields (nVertLevels)
   integer :: varsize       ! variable size (dimlens(1:numdims))
   integer :: index1        ! location in dart state vector of first occurrence
   integer :: indexN        ! location in dart state vector of last  occurrence
   integer :: dart_kind
   character(len=paramname_length) :: kind_string
   logical  :: clamping     ! does variable need to be range-restricted before
   real(r8) :: range(2)     ! lower and upper bounds for the data range.
   logical  :: out_of_range_fail  ! is out of range fatal if range-checking?
end type progvartype

type(progvartype), dimension(max_state_variables) :: progvar

The variables are simply read from the MPAS analysis file and stored in the DART state vector such that all quantities for one variable are stored contiguously. Within each variable; they are stored vertically-contiguous for each horizontal location. From a storage standpoint, this would be equivalent to a Fortran variable dimensioned x(nVertical,nHorizontal,nVariables). The fastest-varying dimension is vertical, then horizontal, then variable … naturally, the DART state vector is 1D. Each variable is also stored this way in the MPAS analysis file.

Compilation

The DART interface for MPAS-ATM can be compiled with various fortran compilers such as (but not limited to) gfortran, pgf90, and intel. It has been tested on a Mac and NCAR IBM supercomputer (yellowstone).

Note

While MPAS requires the PIO (Parallel IO) and pNetCDF (Parallel NetCDF) libraries, DART uses only the plain NetCDF libraries. If an altered NetCDF library is required by the parallel versions, there may be incompatibilities between the run-time requirements of DART and MPAS. Static linking of one or the other executable, or swapping of modules between executions may be necessary.

Conversions

A Welcome Development

MPAS files no longer need to be converted to DART formatted files, they can be read in directly from a input file list!

Analysis File NetCDF header

The header of an MPAS analysis file is presented below - simply for context. Keep in mind that many variables have been removed for clarity. Also keep in mind that the multi-dimensional arrays listed below have the dimensions reversed from the Fortran convention. Note: the variables marked ‘available in dart’ are available as metadata variables in DART. Just to be perfectly clear, they are not ‘state’.

$ ncdump -h mpas_init.nc
netcdf mpas_analysis {
dimensions:
         StrLen = 64 ;
         Time = UNLIMITED ; // (1 currently)
         nCells = 10242 ;                                  available in DART
         nEdges = 30720 ;                                  available in DART
         maxEdges = 10 ;
         maxEdges2 = 20 ;
         nVertices = 20480 ;                               available in DART
         TWO = 2 ;
         THREE = 3 ;
         vertexDegree = 3 ;
         FIFTEEN = 15 ;
         TWENTYONE = 21 ;
         R3 = 3 ;
         nVertLevels = 41 ;                                available in DART
         nVertLevelsP1 = 42 ;                              available in DART
         nMonths = 12 ;
         nVertLevelsP2 = 43 ;
         nSoilLevels = 4 ;                                 available in DART
variables:
         char xtime(Time, StrLen) ;                        available in DART
         double latCell(nCells) ;                          available in DART
         double lonCell(nCells) ;                          available in DART
         double latEdge(nEdges) ;                          available in DART
         double lonEdge(nEdges) ;                          available in DART
         int indexToEdgeID(nEdges) ;
         double latVertex(nVertices) ;
         double lonVertex(nVertices) ;
      double xVertex(nVertices) ;                       available in DART
      double yVertex(nVertices) ;                       available in DART
      double zVertex(nVertices) ;                       available in DART
      double xEdge(nVertices) ;                         available in DART
      double yEdge(nVertices) ;                         available in DART
      double zEdge(nVertices) ;                         available in DART
         int indexToVertexID(nVertices) ;
         int cellsOnEdge(nEdges, TWO) ;
         int nEdgesOnCell(nCells) ;
         int nEdgesOnEdge(nEdges) ;
         int edgesOnCell(nCells, maxEdges) ;               available in DART
         int edgesOnEdge(nEdges, maxEdges2) ;
         double weightsOnEdge(nEdges, maxEdges2) ;
         double dvEdge(nEdges) ;
         double dcEdge(nEdges) ;
         double angleEdge(nEdges) ;
         double edgeNormalVectors(nEdges, R3) ;            available in DART
         double cellTangentPlane(nEdges, TWO, R3) ;
         int cellsOnCell(nCells, maxEdges) ;
         int verticesOnCell(nCells, maxEdges) ;            available in DART
         int verticesOnEdge(nEdges, TWO) ;
         int edgesOnVertex(nVertices, vertexDegree) ;
         int cellsOnVertex(nVertices, vertexDegree) ;      available in DART
         double kiteAreasOnVertex(nVertices, vertexDegree) ;
         double rainc(Time, nCells) ;
         double cuprec(Time, nCells) ;
         double cutop(Time, nCells) ;
         double cubot(Time, nCells) ;
         double relhum(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double qsat(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double graupelnc(Time, nCells) ;
         double snownc(Time, nCells) ;
         double rainnc(Time, nCells) ;
         double graupelncv(Time, nCells) ;
         double snowncv(Time, nCells) ;
         double rainncv(Time, nCells) ;
         double sr(Time, nCells) ;
         double surface_temperature(Time, nCells) ;
         double surface_pressure(Time, nCells) ;
         double coeffs_reconstruct(nCells, maxEdges, R3) ;
         double theta_base(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double rho_base(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double pressure_base(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double exner_base(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double exner(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double h_divergence(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double uReconstructMeridional(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double uReconstructZonal(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double uReconstructZ(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double uReconstructY(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double uReconstructX(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double pv_cell(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double pv_vertex(Time, nVertices, nVertLevels) ;
         double ke(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double rho_edge(Time, nEdges, nVertLevels) ;
         double pv_edge(Time, nEdges, nVertLevels) ;
         double vorticity(Time, nVertices, nVertLevels) ;
         double divergence(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double v(Time, nEdges, nVertLevels) ;
         double rh(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double theta(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double rho(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double qv_init(nVertLevels) ;
         double t_init(nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double u_init(nVertLevels) ;
         double pressure_p(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double tend_theta(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double tend_rho(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double tend_w(Time, nCells, nVertLevelsP1) ;
         double tend_u(Time, nEdges, nVertLevels) ;
         double qv(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double qc(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double qr(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double qi(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double qs(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double qg(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double tend_qg(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double tend_qs(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double tend_qi(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double tend_qr(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double tend_qc(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double tend_qv(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double qnr(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double qni(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double tend_qnr(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;
         double tend_qni(Time, nCells, nVertLevels) ;

Files

filename

purpose

input.nml

to read the namelist - model_mod_nml and mpas_vars_nml

mpas_init.nc

provides model state, and ‘valid_time’ of the model state

static.nc

provides grid dimensions

true_state.nc

the time-history of the “true” model state from an OSSE

preassim.nc

the time-history of the model state before assimilation

analysis.nc

the time-history of the model state after assimilation

dart_log.out [default name]

the run-time diagnostic output

dart_log.nml [default name]

the record of all the namelists actually USED - contains the default values

References

The Data Assimilation section in the MPAS documentation found at http://mpas-dev.github.io.